Greetings. Thanks for friending me. I really like Camera Obscura. I'm sorry you aren't doing any more, but I applaud your wisdom in stopping when you reached the end. That can be a hard thing to do.
Underworld was most definitely a steaming pile of poses, cool shots, pretty people in costumes, and deliberate obscurity without any human warmth or original ideas to make it worth bothering to suspend disbelief. (I knew there was trouble with opening scene. I wondered to myself: OK, she's undead, so a 200+ foot plummet to the street won't actually hurt her--she's supernatural. She still seems to accelerating normally, and she still apparently weights 150 lbs or so, so how come she didn't shatter the pavement when she hit it? Nothing that happened after that was sufficiently interesting to prevent me from returning to that knotty problem.) I kept wondering it Todd McFarlane or Rob Liefeld had been secretly involved in the storyboarding.
However, I would like to offer up the notion that any idea or image, no matter how cliche, can be really nifty if done well. Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon was a beautiful and moving film, visually captivating and almost flawlessly filmed. Yet, none of the effects or tropes in the film were really new, and even I, who has seen very little Chinese cinema of any sort and hasn't watched a lot of kung fu flicks (unlike most gamers it seems), even I was unsurprised by anything I saw. CTHD's strength wasn't in its novelty, but in its using everything well in the service of the story. If some guy had had his head chopped in two, and hadn't realized it for a moment, it would have been cool in CTHD, because Ang Lee and his crew would have done it RIGHT.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Underworld was most definitely a steaming pile of poses, cool shots, pretty people in costumes, and deliberate obscurity without any human warmth or original ideas to make it worth bothering to suspend disbelief. (I knew there was trouble with opening scene. I wondered to myself: OK, she's undead, so a 200+ foot plummet to the street won't actually hurt her--she's supernatural. She still seems to accelerating normally, and she still apparently weights 150 lbs or so, so how come she didn't shatter the pavement when she hit it? Nothing that happened after that was sufficiently interesting to prevent me from returning to that knotty problem.) I kept wondering it Todd McFarlane or Rob Liefeld had been secretly involved in the storyboarding.
However, I would like to offer up the notion that any idea or image, no matter how cliche, can be really nifty if done well. Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon was a beautiful and moving film, visually captivating and almost flawlessly filmed. Yet, none of the effects or tropes in the film were really new, and even I, who has seen very little Chinese cinema of any sort and hasn't watched a lot of kung fu flicks (unlike most gamers it seems), even I was unsurprised by anything I saw. CTHD's strength wasn't in its novelty, but in its using everything well in the service of the story. If some guy had had his head chopped in two, and hadn't realized it for a moment, it would have been cool in CTHD, because Ang Lee and his crew would have done it RIGHT.